Think about the people you took on this summer and in September. Most of them are probably settling in well. One or two may be causing you some doubt: often late, patchy with paperwork, or not quite getting the key person role. For years the answer has been “let’s give it a bit longer and see”. From 1 January 2027 that approach gets a lot riskier.
Two years becomes six months
Under the Employment Rights Act 2025, the qualifying period for an ordinary unfair dismissal claim falls from two years’ service to six months on 1 January 2027. The limit on compensation is also due to be removed on the same date.
At the moment, dismissing someone with less than two years’ service rarely leads to an unfair dismissal claim, unless an automatic protection such as whistleblowing or pregnancy is involved. From January, anyone who has worked for you for six months will be able to challenge a dismissal on the grounds that it was unfair. That includes the practitioner who joined in the summer. A September starter reaches six months in March.
None of this stops you from parting company with someone who isn’t right for the job. It means you’ll need a fair reason, a fair process and records that show both. In practice, probation becomes the main point at which you decide.
Probation that actually decides something
In many settings probation is a date on the contract that passes without anyone noticing. To work under the new rules it needs a structure:
- Clear expectations from the first day. Put in writing what good looks like in the role, from ratios and sleep checks to learning journal updates.
- Reviews at regular points. A short, documented conversation at four, eight and twelve weeks gives an honest picture and plenty of time to improve.
- Support before judgement. If someone is struggling, record what help was offered. Examples include a mentor, extra shadowing or specific training.
- A decision before the deadline. Diary the final review well before the six-month point, and make a clear decision to confirm, extend or end.
Handled like this, probation is fairer to new starters as well. People who know what is expected, and hear early if they are falling short, usually improve. The few who don’t are rarely surprised by the outcome.
Mentors do most of the work
The person who knows best how a new starter is doing is the experienced practitioner working beside them, not the manager. A good mentor shows how things are done, gives feedback in the moment and notices early when someone is finding it hard. They can also give you a fair, specific account at each review. We wrote about this in January in new year, new starters, and the mentoring that makes them stay.
Our Mentoring Apprentices and New Starters course prepares experienced staff for that role, including induction, feedback that sticks and what to do when a mentee struggles. For the manager or room leader running the reviews, Effective Supervision and Appraisal for Early Years Managers covers setting objectives, giving feedback, handling difficult conversations and keeping records.
Turn your experienced practitioners into confident mentors.
Mentoring Apprentices and New Starters covers the mentor’s role, induction, coaching and feedback, and supporting a mentee who is struggling, with an NFAQ-accredited certificate on completion.
Before the Christmas closure, list everyone who has joined since the spring and note where each of them is in their probation. If there’s a conversation you’ve been putting off, have it this month while you still have time to act on it.
This article was published in October 2026. Commencement dates for the Employment Rights Act 2025 are set by government and can change, so check GOV.UK for the current position and take advice on individual cases. It is not legal advice.

